Money Carriers Leave on the Table After Accidents: What Insurance Won’t Tell You
Insurance companies aren’t going to present your claim for you.
If you don’t know what you’re entitled to, you’re not going to get it. And if you don’t ask for it, you won’t get it either.
In this episode of This Week in Trucking, we sit down with Jennifer from Claim Shield, a former State Farm claims handler who now works as a third-party claims recovery expert for trucking companies and carriers with commercial vehicles. She’s spent years inside the insurance system, and now she uses that knowledge to make sure carriers get every dollar they’re owed.
If you’ve been involved in an accident that wasn’t your fault, even years ago, this conversation might be worth real money to you.
Episode Highlights
The Most Expensive Assumption: “Insurance Will Handle It”
“If you don’t know what you’re entitled to, you’re not going to get it. You don’t ask for it, you won’t get it.” — Jennifer
Most owner-operators and small carriers assume that once they file a claim, the insurance company will make them whole. That’s not how it works.
Insurance companies will pay what they think they owe — not necessarily what you’re actually entitled to. They’re not going to tell you about additional claims you could be making. And sometimes they’ll send you 50% of your estimate in a check, hoping you’ll cash it and move on.
If you don’t know the game, you lose by default.t those, you can’t do seamless border crossings — and the opportunity disappears.
The Money Carriers Don’t Know They Can Recover
Jennifer breaks down three types of claims that carriers almost always miss:
Loss of use — when your truck is being repaired because of someone else’s negligence, you’ve lost the use and enjoyment of your property. That time has value. And no, the other company can’t tell you to “get it fixed during your driver’s reset.” Your sleeper is where your driver lives. That’s their home.
Diminished value — if your truck was in an accident and was properly repaired, it’s still worth less than an identical truck that wasn’t in an accident. That gap is diminished value, and in many states, it’s a valid claim.
Lost revenue — separate from loss of use. In some states you can collect both. If your truck was off the road and you lost loads, that’s revenue the other party’s negligence cost you.
“If you don’t know you’re entitled to other things, you’re losing money.” — Jennifer
One Closed File Review: $7,700 Recovered
Jennifer’s team did a closed file review for a moving company. From one single claim, they recovered $7,700 — $4,700 from a cargo damage payment that was owed back, plus loss of use for the trailer while it was being repaired.
The company had already made a claim. But they only asked for repairs. They didn’t know they could recover more.
“If you just have the mindset ‘insurance will handle it,’ and you don’t know what you’re entitled to, you’re not going to get it.” — Jennifer
What to Do at the Scene of an Accident
Most carriers are told to just get the other company’s DOT number. Jennifer says that’s not enough.
Take pictures of:
The other driver’s cab card Their insurance card Their driver’s license Both vehicles at the scene before anything is moved — showing the point of contact Any damage, debris, or road conditions
“Pictures don’t lie. When the other company says ‘we had no vehicles in that area,’ pictures end that conversation.” — Jennifer
And invest in a quality dash cam. Jennifer has seen recoveries fall apart because footage was blurry or unusable. It’s worth spending more for a better camera — and making sure it’s activated at all times.
Denied Claims Aren’t Always Denied
“Just because an adjuster tells you the claim is denied doesn’t mean it really is.” — Jennifer
Jennifer has gotten liability decisions reversed. She’s had denied claims paid. She called one insurance company four times before someone admitted a claim existed.
Insurance adjusters aren’t always knowledgeable about every coverage type. Sometimes it takes escalation to their attorneys — and even attorneys have reversed decisions when presented with a solid case.
The point: don’t take “no” at face value. Have someone who knows how to present the claim.
Every Carrier Should Have a Claims Recovery Expert
“There’s no fee unless there’s a recovery. There’s really no downside.” — Jennifer
Jennifer operates on a contingency model — she only gets paid when she recovers money for you. Closed file reviews are free. And she goes back through years of prior accidents to find money that was left behind.
For small carriers who are already stretched thin between driving, dispatching, compliance, and running the business, having a claims expert means someone is fighting for your money while you focus on your operation.
Cash Flow After an Accident Is Where Small Carriers Get Hurt
Accidents create immediate financial pressure. Repair costs, downtime, deductibles, towing — all hitting while you’re waiting on insurance to process. And if you’re also waiting 30–60 days for freight brokers to pay outstanding invoices, the cash crunch compounds fast.
That’s where Bobtail comes in. Same-day pay on loads you’ve already hauled — so one accident doesn’t shut down your whole operation while you wait for checks to arrive.
Check out Bobtail’s financial tools for cash flow →
Talk to our team about your operation →
Stay Ahead of the Freight Market!
Subscribe to This Week in Trucking’s FREE Newsletter
Want to know which freight markets are hot right now — broken down by equipment type — plus broker alerts so you can avoid the shady players in the industry?
This Week in Trucking is a completely free newsletter that delivers the intel you need to make smarter decisions and protect your trucking business.
Subscribe to the free newsletter here →
And don’t forget to subscribe to the YouTube channel so you never miss conversations like this one. Drive safe, everyone.
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions: FMCSA Compliance for Trucking Companies in 2026
What should I do at the scene of a trucking accident?
Take photos of everything: the other driver’s cab card, insurance card, driver’s license, both vehicles before they’re moved, and the point of contact. Don’t rely on just getting a DOT number.
What is loss of use, and can carriers claim it?
Loss of use is compensation for the time your truck is off the road being repaired due to someone else’s negligence. In many states, it’s a valid claim, and it covers the entire repair period — not just business hours.
What is diminished value for trucks?
After an accident, even a properly repaired truck is worth less than an identical one with no accident history. That gap is diminished value, and in many states, you can file a claim for it.
Can carriers recover lost revenue after an accident?
In some states, yes. Lost revenue is separate from loss of use. If your truck was down and you missed loads, that’s a recoverable claim in certain jurisdictions.
What is a closed file review?
A claims expert reviews your past accident files to find money that was never recovered — unclaimed loss of use, diminished value, underpaid repairs, or claims that were improperly denied. Jennifer’s team recovered $7,700 from a single closed claim.
How long after an accident can I still recover money?
It depends on the state’s statute of limitations where the accident occurred. But claims experts typically review the last couple of years of accident history to find unclaimed money.
Why do insurance companies underpay trucking claims?
Insurance companies pay what they think they owe, not what you’re entitled to. They won’t volunteer information about additional claims you could make. And sometimes they’ll send a partial payment hoping you’ll cash it and close the file.
Should small carriers invest in better dash cams?
Absolutely. Jennifer has seen recoveries fail because the footage was blurry or unusable. Spend more for a quality camera, keep it activated at all times, and make sure it captures the detail needed to prove your case.
How can small carriers manage cash flow after an accident?
Accidents create immediate costs — repairs, towing, downtime — while insurance takes time to process. Bobtail’s financial tools let you turn unpaid invoices into same-day working capital, so one accident doesn’t shut down your operation.
How do I find the most profitable freight lanes while my truck is being repaired?
The This Week in Trucking free newsletter breaks down the hottest freight markets by equipment type every Monday. When your truck is back on the road, you’ll know exactly which lanes are paying — plus broker alerts so you avoid the shady players.
How can carriers stay updated?
Subscribe to This Week in Trucking’s FREE newsletter for weekly insights on fuel prices, market updates, and interviews with successful carriers who share real strategies that work. Subscribe here.
What is freight factoring, and how does it help owner-operators?
Freight factoring (also called accounts receivable factoring or invoice factoring) is when a factoring company purchases your unpaid invoices and pays you immediately — typically within 24 hours. This gives owner-operators and small carriers the working capital they need to cover fuel, maintenance, and compliance costs without waiting 30–60 days for freight brokers to pay.
How do I find the most profitable lanes for my equipment type?
This Week in Trucking’s FREE newsletter breaks down the hottest freight markets by equipment type every Monday — plus broker alerts so you know which lanes are paying and which players to avoid.
Full Transcript
Article By
Keep Learning






