How Small Fleets Stay Profitable at $2/Mile Hauling Produce
Small carriers often assume brokers hold all the power—but according to Daushawn Falls, founder of Tenacity Express Freight Brokerage, carriers have more leverage than they think. In this episode of This Week in Trucking, he breaks down how owner-operators can negotiate stronger rates, build profitable broker relationships, and stand out in a tightening 2025 freight market.
Whether you run one truck or a small fleet, this conversation is loaded with real-world tactics to help you get better freight, avoid costly mistakes, and operate like a true business—exactly what brokers want to see when choosing who gets the load.
Episode Highlights
HHow Daushawn Started in Trucking—and Why He Shifted to Brokering
Daushawn began driving in 2012, spent years running his own fleet, and eventually learned the hard way that scaling trucking is expensive and unforgiving without strong cash flow.
That’s why he built Tenacity Express and now works closely with carriers every day:
“Carriers underestimate their power. If you show up professional, communicate, and know your numbers—you become the one brokers want to call first.”
The Biggest Misconception About Brokers
Daushawn is brutally honest:
No, brokers aren’t getting rich on every load.
Some loads pay well, others lose money. Brokers rely on consistency—not “killing it” every time. What carriers don’t see is the swings:
- High-margin loads that carry the slow weeks
- Loss-leader freight just to keep a customer
- Market cycles where carriers hold the stronger position
He believes 2025 is shifting into a carrier-favored market, and carriers who negotiate confidently will win.
How Small Carriers Can Negotiate Rates More Effectively
His advice is simple and constant:
Know your numbers.
If you know your cost per mile and stick to it, a broker will respect you.
“If you tell me your number and you’re firm, more often than not—that’s the rate that goes.”
The carriers who crumble or lowball themselves lose out.
The #1 Mistake Carriers Make When Booking Freight
Daushawn says it without hesitation:
Poor communication.
The biggest failures happen when drivers don’t:
- Provide updates
- Report delays
- Send paperwork immediately
- Follow instructions on pickup/drop order
One mistake yesterday? A carrier reversed their stop order without telling anyone.
Not a disaster—but enough to damage trust.
In a world where customers demand real-time data, communication is currency.
What Brokers Look for When Onboarding Carriers
Daushawn evaluates more than price:
- Clean communication
- Consistent updates
- Professionalism
- History of successful load movement
- Ability to make him look good to the shipper
He works with Trinity Logistics, which means he has visibility into a carrier’s past—good or bad. Mistakes don’t disqualify you, but a refusal to communicate does.
Technology Matters More Than Ever
Tracking is non-negotiable.
He frequently sees:
- MacroPoint
- Project44
- Samsara share links
For high-value freight—metal, construction equipment—shippers expect visibility.
If you don’t track, you don’t get the load.
Paperwork Is the Key to Fast Payments
No surprise:
Bad paperwork delays payment every time.
He sees:
- Blurry PODs
- Missing in/out times
- Mismatched load numbers
- Handwriting no one can read
Good paperwork = fast money.
Bad paperwork = headaches for everyone.
What He’d Do Differently If Starting Over
Instead of starting in reefer, Daushawn says he’d jump straight into:
- Construction materials
- Flatbed
- Heavy haul
- Project freight
Why? More stability, better margins, stronger relationships.
The Power of In-Person Prospecting
Daushawn tells an incredible story about walking into a shipper in San Bernardino:
A warehouse worker introduced him to the manager, who originally didn’t want to talk. One conversation later—he had a new customer sending freight weekly.
“Carriers, you have this power. You can walk into shippers and win freight if you have assets.”
This is your edge over brokers. Use it.
A Positive Outlook for 2026
Despite market volatility, Daushawn is optimistic:
“There’s still a ton of opportunity. 2026 is going to be a great year.”
With bankruptcies rising and capacity tightening, new and small carriers who operate professionally will get more chances—if they step into them.
Factor Smarter, Grow Stronger
At Bobtail, we help carriers like Golden Key Express stay cash-flow positive with no hidden fees. Get same or next-day payments for the loads you deliver, and free up cash for fuel, insurance, and maintenance — the real costs of scaling a fleet.
Learn more about hassle-free factoring with Bobtail and take control of your business today. Contact us here.
Stay Updated
Subscribe to our free newsletter to get weekly updates on freight markets by equipment type, interviews with small carriers, and expert insights to help you grow your business the right way.
FAQs
How can small carriers negotiate stronger rates with brokers in 2025?
Stick to your cost per mile and communicate clearly—brokers respect carriers who know their numbers and hold firm.
What do brokers look for when selecting carriers for high-value or time-sensitive freight?
Tracking compliance, clean communication, accurate paperwork, and a history of reliable deliveries.
What mistakes hurt small carriers the most after they accept a load?
Failing to update the broker, delaying paperwork, changing plans without informing dispatch, or ignoring tracking requirements.
How can a small carrier stand out and build long-term relationships with brokers?
Provide proactive updates, follow instructions, track loads, and operate professionally—brokers prioritize relationships and consistency.
Is heavy haul or construction freight a better option for small carriers looking for stability?
Daushawn recommends yes—project freight tends to pay better and offer longer-term opportunities than commodity freight.
What are the best ways to retain reefer drivers?
Offer consistent home time, fair pay, and transparent communication — drivers stay longer when treated as partners, not just truck numbers.
How can a carrier get paid faster after completing a load?
Submit clear, legible paperwork immediately; include in/out times; and use a reliable factoring service like Bobtail for same-day pay.
Where can I stay updated on trucking market trends?
Subscribe to This Week in Trucking’s FREE newsletter for weekly insights on fuel prices, market updates, and interviews with successful carriers who share real strategies that work. Subscribe here.
What role does in-person prospecting play for small carriers today?
It’s still extremely effective—shippers respond well to asset-based carriers who show up, introduce themselves, and offer capacity.
Full Transcript
Article By
Keep Learning












