Freight Fraud Every Carrier Must Know About: How Truckers Are Getting Robbed in 2025
The trucking industry is facing a wave of sophisticated scams that are costing carriers thousands — from double brokering to identity theft and load hijacking. In this episode of This Week in Trucking, Amy sits down with Robert “Pedro” Peterson, senior agent at Synergy Freight and co-host of The Logistics Lounge, to unpack how carriers can protect their business and what simple steps can save you from becoming the next victim of freight fraud.
Episode Highlights
The Hidden Cost of Fraud in Trucking
Pedro explains that while his own company has avoided major fraud losses, it’s only because they’ve invested in tech, vigilance, and training.
“We’re not victims because my boss pays attention to every little detail. But that takes time, effort, and money — and a lot of carriers just don’t have that.”
For many small fleets and owner-operators, fraud comes down to one thing — not double-checking paperwork. Most scams start with small red flags that go unnoticed: mismatched emails, slightly altered rate cons, or new carriers with incomplete authority.
Pedro shared a story about a double-brokered hotshot load out of California that nearly cost everyone involved thousands. It was only saved because the real carrier checked the BOL and noticed the broker’s name didn’t match the paperwork.
The Right Way to Protect Your Loads
Pedro’s top advice: check everything.
- Verify every document — from rate cons to BOLs.
- Match broker names, phone numbers, and MCs before you haul.
- If something feels off, call the original broker directly to confirm.
- Avoid oversharing — your carrier packet, insurance, and EIN should only go to verified brokers.
He also recommends using tools like Freight Validate — a platform created to help brokers, carriers, and shippers cross-check one another. “It’s not about being paranoid,” Pedro says. “It’s about protecting yourself in a market where bad actors are getting smarter.”
How Scams Are Evolving in 2025
Pedro warns that fraudsters are adapting fast — especially online. High-value thefts like the $1 million tequila load stolen in California weren’t pulled off by amateurs. “These aren’t people breaking into trucks at rest stops anymore,” he says. “These are organized digital crimes — fake brokers, fake rate cons, and fake dispatch services.”
And while he avoided giving specifics (to not help scammers), Pedro emphasized one universal rule: if it’s too good to be true, it probably is.
Smart Moves for Small Carriers
When asked how owner-operators can stay profitable and safe, Pedro gave simple, powerful advice:
- Stop oversharing sensitive data with third-party dispatchers.
- Know your cost per mile. Too many carriers run loads below operating cost.
- Keep preventive maintenance on schedule. Waiting for breakdowns costs far more.
- Use factoring strategically. Reliable cash flow keeps you from taking risky “too good to be true” loads just to stay afloat.
At Bobtail, we make that easy with no hidden fees, and same or next-day payments. That means you can haul confidently, knowing your money will hit your account fast — not 30 days later. Contact us to learn more.
Why Community Matters
This spirit of community is at the heart of This Week in Trucking too. That’s why every week, we share real conversations with fleet owners and experts breaking down the true cost per mile, real profits, and industry trends that matter.
Subscribe to our free newsletter to get weekly updates on freight markets by equipment type, interviews with small carriers, and expert insights to help you grow your business the right way.
Stay Updated
Subscribe to our free newsletter to get weekly updates on freight markets by equipment type, interviews with small carriers, and expert insights to help you grow your business the right way.
Episode FAQs
How much does trucking insurance cost for new authorities in 2025?
Most new authorities pay between $15,000–$30,000 annually for insurance. Premiums are highest in the first years and gradually come down as carriers establish safe records.
What factors affect trucking insurance premiums the most?
Driving history, CSA/SMS scores, equipment type, operating region, and commodities hauled are the biggest factors. Even one CSA alert can cause rates to spike.
How can small carriers lower their insurance premiums long term?
Focus on safety and compliance, use dash cams, maintain your trucks, and work closely with your broker. Building a consistent, low-risk profile is the best way to see reductions at renewal.
Should carriers shop for insurance every year?
Not always. Constant shopping can hurt your reputation with underwriters. It’s better to shop strategically—when you face a large renewal increase or need additional coverage.
What mistakes make trucking insurance more expensive?
Common mistakes include hiring uninsurable drivers, ignoring CSA alerts, failing to disclose operational changes, and hauling loads without confirming coverage.
Can brokers really negotiate lower premiums?
Yes. Experienced trucking brokers can advocate with underwriters, frame your business in the best light, and often secure better terms than a generalist broker.
How can factoring help with insurance costs?
Factoring ensures you have reliable cash flow to cover insurance payments, fuel, and maintenance without waiting on slow broker payments. This reduces financial strain, especially for new authorities.
Managing cash flow is just as important as lowering insurance costs. At Bobtail, we offer hassle-free factoring with no hidden fees. That means you get same or next-day payments for delivered loads at a simple, transparent rate, so you can stay focused on running your business, not chasing invoices.
Full Transcript
Article By
Keep Learning












