FMCSA Targets California in $40M Penalty Over CDL Enforcement Failures

By
Amy Chavez
–

Following months of confusion over the non-domiciled CDL mandate, the FMCSA has taken decisive action, and California is paying the price. The DOT confirmed this week that the state will lose $40 million in federal highway funds for failing to verify English Language Proficiency (ELP) among CDL holders. This penalty signals a broader push for compliance that could reshape how small carriers hire, onboard, and manage drivers nationwide.

The fallout is already spreading beyond California. States across the country are reviewing their licensing procedures for non-domiciled CDL drivers, while carriers are bracing for stricter inspections and longer driver onboarding times. Combined with rising insurance costs and regulatory pressure, this latest crackdown could reshape hiring and compliance for small fleets nationwide.

At the same time, freight rates are showing new volatility. According to the latest DAT Trendlines, spot market rates are climbing in several regions as capacity tightens — particularly for local and regional hauls. For small carriers and box truck operators, that means both opportunity and risk: higher pay per mile, but a smaller pool of compliant drivers to cover demand.

Here’s what’s really happening and how you can protect your business as these new regulations hit your lanes.

Subscribe now!

California Faces Federal Penalties Over CDL Enforcement

Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy announced that California’s failure to verify English proficiency among CDL holders triggered federal funding cuts. The FMCSA cited safety concerns after thousands of drivers failed new ELP checks in other states, sparking a broader review that now includes Washington and New Mexico.

What this means for carriers:

  • Expect tighter roadside inspections and stricter verification at weigh stations.
  • Longer delays for new CDL applicants — especially those from non-domiciled backgrounds.
  • Potential rate increases if the driver pool shrinks, tightening available capacity.

The Non-Domiciled CDL Crackdown: What’s Happened Since

The FMCSA began auditing states earlier this year for issuing CDLs to non-U.S. residents without proper domicile verification. Since then:

  • Over 9,000 CDLs have been flagged or suspended nationwide.
  • Several training schools lost certification for falsified residency records.
  • Illinois, California, and Texas have ramped up document checks, leading to longer onboarding times.

Carriers relying on foreign-born or visa-holding drivers are already feeling the impact. As states enforce stricter documentation, fleets could face driver shortages, higher turnover, and more frequent compliance audits.

Spot Market Reaction and Box Truck Opportunities

While many CDL drivers are facing uncertainty, the box truck segment may benefit from the shake-up. As some CDL trucks drop out of service, spot market rates for local and regional loads are rising — particularly in California, Arizona, and the Midwest.

According to the latest data from DAT Freight & Analytics (September 2025):

  • Dry van: $2.05/mile (up 2¢ MoM)
  • Reefer: $2.44/mile (up 3¢ MoM)
  • Flatbed: $2.50/mile (up 1¢ MoM)
  • Box truck: $2.00–$4.00/mile regionally

For owner-operators running 16–26 ft box trucks, this could be a window of opportunity — especially for local freight, short regional hauls, or contracted routes where demand is surging.

✅ Pro tip: Keep your paperwork clean — ELP, domicile proof, and insurance certificates ready to go. Brokers are tightening verification, and compliance is now a competitive advantage.

What Carriers Should Be Doing Right Now

  1. Audit your drivers — verify domicile documentation, ELP compliance, and CDL status.
  2. Adjust your spot rates based on tightening regional capacity.
  3. Keep documentation organized — roadside inspections are increasing nationwide.
  4. Stay informed — subscribe to industry news and spot rate updates weekly.

How to Protect Cash Flow During Regulatory Delays

With stricter audits and processing slowdowns, payment delays can crush small carriers. Instead of waiting 30+ days for brokers to pay, many fleets are turning to factoring for fast, reliable funding.

💳 At Bobtail, we offer hassle-free factoring with no hidden fees. You get same or next-day payments for your loads and a simple, transparent rate — so you can keep your cash flow steady while focusing on compliance. Learn more.

Subscribe now!

Spot market rate data sourced from DAT Freight & Analytics, September 2025

Episode FAQs

What is the FMCSA’s Non-Domiciled CDL Crackdown?

It’s a federal effort to ensure all CDL holders have a verifiable U.S. domicile and work authorization. The FMCSA is auditing states that issued CDLs to non-residents without proper proof, resulting in mass suspensions and delays.

Why did California lose $40 million in federal highway funding?

The DOT determined California wasn’t enforcing English Language Proficiency requirements for commercial drivers, violating federal safety standards.

How does the crackdown affect small carriers?

Expect longer processing times for driver onboarding, more roadside checks, and increased demand for compliant drivers, which could raise rates in some markets.

Are box truck operators impacted by the crackdown?

Indirectly — as CDL drivers exit the market, box truck operators are seeing higher load availability and rates, especially for regional and last-mile freight.

How can carriers prepare for ELP and domicile verification?

Audit your drivers, maintain proper records (utility bills, lease agreements, etc.), and keep digital copies ready for broker requests or DOT audits.

Can stricter driver enforcement raise freight rates?

Yes — a smaller compliant driver pool often leads to capacity shortages, pushing spot market rates higher for certain regions or load types.

Where can carriers get help managing cash flow during the crackdown?

Factoring companies like Bobtail offer flexible, same-day funding to keep carriers liquid even when load payments slow down.

📬 Stay Updated

Subscribe to the This Week in Trucking newsletter for weekly breakdowns of freight trends, and carrier interviews that reveal real cost-per-mile data and profits.e supply chain.

Full Transcript

Speaker: [00:00:00] From this week in trucking, this is hot right now and I’m Amy. There’s been a lot of noise in the trucking world this week

Speaker: from California facing new federal penalties

Speaker: to how the fmcsa, non domiciled CDL crackdown.

Speaker: Is shaking out across state lines,

Speaker: and of course, we’ll look into what this means for the one to two truck owner operator, as well as box truck owners.

Speaker: but before we get into it, don’t forget to subscribe so you’re never miss an update.

Speaker: your support. Helps us keep bringing weekly videos and interviews your way.

Speaker: Let’s start with a big headline. Transportation Secretary, Sean Duffy,

Speaker: announced that the federal government is withholding over $40 million

Speaker: in highway funds from California.

Speaker: For failing to enforce the English language proficiency standards for CDL holders.

Speaker: That means now California is under pressure to prove its screening and testing

Speaker: commercial drivers properly,

Speaker: not just issuing licenses to anyone who passes the road test.

Speaker: The DOT has cited safety concerns.

Speaker: After thousands of drivers [00:01:00] reportedly failed the ELP checks in other states,

Speaker: and it’s not just California, Washington, and New Mexico are also under review for similar issues.

Speaker: So expect tighter enforcement across the board.

Speaker: Roadside checks, new testing requirements.

Speaker: And delays for carriers onboarding, non-English speaking drivers until they pass the assessments.

Speaker: Let me know in the comments what you think of this kind of enforcement for improving safety, or if you think this only slows down the system.

Speaker: as you might know, a few months ago, the F-M-C-S-A,

Speaker: began auditing states that were Issuing CDLs to non-US residents without proper domicile verification.

Speaker: When the rule hit at first, people thought it might blow over, but of course it didn’t. here’s what’s happened since.

Speaker: over 9,000. CDLs have now been flagged or suspended nationwide.

Speaker: This is all according to state enforcement data compiled since August.

Speaker: States like Illinois, California, and Texas have all increased document verification,

Speaker: [00:02:00] meaning longer lines, slower processing, tighter scrutiny for new applicants.

Speaker: Several training schools lost their certification. After

Speaker: investigators found irregularities in how they.

Speaker: Verified student residency,

Speaker: and most importantly, the carriers are feeling it.

Speaker: many fleets that relied on foreign-born or visa holding drivers have seen disruptions, especially in local and regional freight.

Speaker: The F-M-C-S-A says that the crackdown will continue into 2026.

Speaker: aiming to ensure that every CDL holder has a verifiable US address and Legal work authorization

Speaker: for owner operators. This means more inspection stops, more document checks.

Speaker: Possibly higher rates if the available driver pool keeps tightening,

Speaker: let us know in the comments if you’re seeing more delays or document checks in waste stations lately.

Speaker: when the driver pool shrinks the spot market usually reacts fast.

Speaker: And we’re already seeing early signs of that.

Speaker: there is a slight upward pressure on drive van and box trucks in several regions, Especially [00:03:00] California, Arizona, and Illinois.

Speaker: Rates are rapidly climbing as capacity vanishes, particularly in regions with high enforcement like Southern California and the Midwest.

Speaker: for dry van rates are climbing rapidly as capacity vanishes, particularly in regions With high enforcement like Southern California and the Midwest. for reefer high value, perishable loads are seeing strong rate growth due to the immediate capacity crunch and seasonal harvests For flatbed rates are stable to rising, benefiting from the general market tightening, even though the demand for construction industrial goods is soft, For box truck not directly targeted by the CDL crackdown. Benefits from the spillover. large loads that can’t find a 50 foot dry van are being broken down and offered to smaller non CDL box trucks pushing regional rates up.

Speaker: For box truck operators, this could actually mean an opportunity.

Speaker: If you’re running a box truck under your own authority,

Speaker: Your rates might rise for local and regional deliveries,

Speaker: especially [00:04:00] if large carriers are failing to fill that capacity.

Speaker: But don’t get too comfortable.

Speaker: some brokers are responding by tightening contracts and asking for extra driver documentation.

Speaker: CDL scans, domicile proof ELP records before releasing the freight.

Speaker: A pro tip, keep your compliance and documentation clean

Speaker: because that’s now a competitive advantage in the spot market.

Speaker: Also, let us know if you actually have noticed brokers. Asking for more paperwork or maybe longer wait times before approving loads. tell us in the comments what you’re seeing out there.

Speaker: As we said in previous videos, talking about non domicile CDLs, this is what carriers need to know.

Speaker: Audit your drivers. Make sure they have a valid CDL domicile documentation and ELP verification if needed.

Speaker: Stay informed on the spot rates movements.

Speaker: And if capacity does tighten, adjust your minimums, but be realistic about your liens.

Speaker: And lastly, keep your paperwork organized. The F-M-C-S-A is watching the states and the states are watching you.

Speaker: A clean compliance [00:05:00] file can save you from an expensive headache later.

Speaker: If you want more quick updates, sign up for this weekend Trucking’s free newsletter. We break down the best cities pickup loads

Speaker: by equipment type plus interviews with carriers sharing their real cost per mile and profits.

Speaker: Click the link in the description of this video.

Speaker: And let me know in the comments, will tighter driver enforcement actually raise our rates

Speaker: or just raise your costs. Don’t forget to subscribe and drive safe.

Amy Chavez Avatar

Article By

Amy Chavez
Amy is the editor and producer of the This Week In Trucking podcast alongside managing social media content with a focus on providing helpful information and clear communication. She enjoys making content that informs and connects, helping audiences engage with stories that matter.

Keep learning with weekly trucking freight market updates.

Keep Learning

Subscribe to our Newsletter

We are committed to your privacy. Bobtail uses the information your provide to us to contact you about our relevant content.You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information, check out our privacy page.